My Chinese frame and motor build. The CHEEB, V1.0 - Build Thread

Rob Rides EMTB

Administrator
Staff member
Subscriber
Jan 14, 2018
6,260
13,700
Surrey, UK
Another ride today.

13 miles / 1167 ft climbing I returned with 79% battery remaining! I was using the highest power mode all ride. Temperature of 3 degrees (usually has an impact on range). Conditions: MUD!!

Bafang M500

On the ride today it definitely felt LESS punchy and powerful than most other motors. Not hugely less powerful, but definitely noticeable if you're used to others. Its power delivery is way more progressive. So you get a small amount of assist to get going then power is delivered nicely.

To compare this motor to a Levo with the 90Nm Brose Mag S, its like acceleration setting is on 0% on mission control.

I hope one day to be able to tune the motor, if Bafang allow it. I'd change the acceleration response (I like the kick that you can get from the Bosch / Brose upon initial pedal stroke)

Assistance is always very very smooth. No surges of power, no twitchiness of the motor.

Motor is so quiet! Super stealth, walkers just cannot hear you coming. No one can hear it! (check my Insta story today if you want to hear it in action)

I think that Bafang have detuned this motor and I reckon its capable of a fair bit more. But as its aimed at the euro market no doubt they've turned the power down a fair bit (its a very similar design to the peddle M600 motor that is way more powerful).

This crazy 840Wh battery and motor tune will provide some epic long rides. Paired with the frame, it'd be amazing as a big climbing machine for some epic descents. Alps, for example. It'd just cruise for miles up the climbs then give you an amazing chassis to smash it back down.

I need to do a full battery range test at some point to work out battery estimation accuracy.

tempImageFubn9G.jpg


Dengfu E10 Frame

Totally solid. Trails, jumps. Plush feeling frame kinematic, not too wooden feeling. RockShox Zeb is total overkill for todays ride, but its so solid. Need to reduce PSI a little.

Not much more to say about the frame other than so far its doing well (3 short rides!). Again, totally quiet.
 

Rob Rides EMTB

Administrator
Staff member
Subscriber
Jan 14, 2018
6,260
13,700
Surrey, UK
There's talk of the screen settings being able to give 5 and 9 levels, are you sure that on the other settings, say the 9th setting, will not get more assist ? Certainly other riders are saying that the M500 is comparable to the Bosch and Bafung claim 85Nm of torque for the M500 and 120Nm for the M600, which should be comparible ?
I tried levels 5 and 9 also ?

With a setting of 3/3 - Level 3 is the equivalent of level 9 (it just removes all the in between marginal assist levels, so 3/3 = 9/9)


Bafang claim 95Nm for this which is more than both Brose and Bosch. In my experience though it’s definitely not as punchy as both of those.
 

apac

E*POWAH Elite World Champion
Aug 14, 2019
1,326
1,173
S.Wales
You'll probably find that the m600 has one metal gear inside along with the nylon ones to help take the extra load and to stop the gears turning into peanut butter when run at higher amperage. Which in turn will make the motor a lot more audible.

 

Rob Rides EMTB

Administrator
Staff member
Subscriber
Jan 14, 2018
6,260
13,700
Surrey, UK
Thats a bit of a pain, thought the 3/3 would be the same as the 9/9 but worth a punt.

Are you underestimating the max output perhaps if the acceleration has been wound back ( the M600 had the same plastic main drive gear but in its early production run, the motor power stripped it and they went over to a metal gear ) and the engine is quiet with a slow kick in to prevent damage to the plastic gear on intial drive. We've all been in super quiet and super smooth cars that just outpace the V8 next door.

I think somewhere on the display is a motor Watt readout ?
The max watts I've seen on the display is 580W. Compare that to the Brose, I've seen way over 700W.

Similar to here - almost 800W from the Brose (electrical power)

I'm going to contact Bafang to see if there's any newer revisions to the firmware they can supply me. Also, I read that @patdam mention his felt less powerful than his Shimano, so we are both probably using the same firmware and getting the same power output.
 

Rob Rides EMTB

Administrator
Staff member
Subscriber
Jan 14, 2018
6,260
13,700
Surrey, UK
Am I right in saying same motor I usedd in Class 2 Pedlecs with a different tune?
No, they use the M600 motor in the Class 2. Fitting is the same but the motor is slightly wider. 500W nominal and like 120Nm / 1000 Watts
 

Rob Rides EMTB

Administrator
Staff member
Subscriber
Jan 14, 2018
6,260
13,700
Surrey, UK
@Rob Rides EMTB could you maybe measure the seat tube angle? with your mullet setup and the 170mm fork I would expect you are sitting quite far over the rear wheel, or is the climbing position still acceptable?
I measured effective seat angle at around 75 degrees. BUT i need to do it again with more accuracy.

Due to the 455mm chain stay no issue with climbing so far.
 

patdam

Well-known member
Jan 17, 2019
902
601
france
The max watts I've seen on the display is 580W. Compare that to the Brose, I've seen way over 700W.

Similar to here - almost 800W from the Brose (electrical power)

I'm going to contact Bafang to see if there's any newer revisions to the firmware they can supply me. Also, I read that @patdam mention his felt less powerful than his Shimano, so we are both probably using the same firmware and getting the same power output.

Less powerful feel yes, but more torque. That provide an motor more efficient to climb on hard technical track and you can use more long demultiplication. Where i need to use walk mode to climb with shimano, i playing to climb on the bike with the dengfu. To bafang i request more the possibility to reduce throttle max power and displaying information selected in large characters place of speed meter. I have also request explaination on BESST tool, does final customer can use it (it seem necessary to have password) ?

We seem on line ROB about the feelling of this motor, we shouldn't so far from the truth. An noisless motor is really great pleasure.

Good luck to find the range limit rob, i could not (you have light to ride night ?).

i do not ride in the alps, but pyrenees is not bad place

sig6.jpg
 
Last edited:

Rob Rides EMTB

Administrator
Staff member
Subscriber
Jan 14, 2018
6,260
13,700
Surrey, UK
Wow...I am amazed buy that range!! I am actually considering getting a non ludicrous controller for my 600 on the X1 as it is more then powerful enough and I would love more range!

Rob would you ever consider bolting up the M600 on this bike or is that a no go? That motor is seriously impressive.
The reason I didnt go for the M600 was that I really need to keep it legal! The M600 is not an EU spec (as its derestricted / more powah!!) and I cant really go condoning that kinda stuff ?

Also, the weight, its quite a bit heavier.
 

aarfeldt

E*POWAH Master
Subscriber
May 25, 2019
713
634
Denmark, Danstrup
How is the speed controlled ?
Magnet on rear brake disc and pickup on chainstay ?

Who sets the cutout speed ?
I assume it can be delivered with both 25kmh/32kmh, depending on the region it's supposed to be used..??..

Is there an app to change/modify/personalize the settings ?
 

Zimmerframe

MUPPET
Subscriber
Jun 12, 2019
14,028
20,818
Brittany, France
How is the speed controlled ?
Magnet on rear brake disc and pickup on chainstay ?

Who sets the cutout speed ?
I assume it can be delivered with both 25kmh/32kmh, depending on the region it's supposed to be used..??..

Is there an app to change/modify/personalize the settings ?
Pedalling .. Though there is an optional thumb throttle. Or bum throttle if you mounted it on the seat.
I think the Magnet, as supplied is a wheel magnet. You can just about see the sensor on the inside of the chainstay on the youtube image.

They do when you order it. For UK delivery it's set at 25kmh.

There is an app you can download from the bafang website called "BESST". If you're not techno savvy, I you might also need to buy a "BESST" connection for to link to your PC for about €100 - From what I recall, these are available from the luna website. You then need a logon id for the software which Bafang can provide. As mentioned in the thread, different ID's have different capabilities with regard to what settings they will let you change and within what parameters.
 

Animalector

Active member
Jan 2, 2021
53
83
Cairns, Australia
really nice bike, correct me if I am wrong but surely all Bafang motors are illegal and do more than 250 watts? I have in mind that when I checked Bafang they had no engine that was legal from what I could find.
No the M500 is EN15194 compliant, which is 250W nominal and PAS only to 25km/h. All brands, Shimano, Brose, Bosch all peak higher than 250W because of the way the standards specify how to.measure the nominal power. Basically because you're climbing up a hill much slower than 25km/h you're allowed to output more power.
 

GrandPaBrogan

⚡ eGeezer ⚡
Oct 5, 2019
1,329
2,068
New Zealand
hmm, indeed not the same.. could be the same internals, in a different case. That's some serious investment in tooling. I've been thinking about the "light weight" enduro rather than going bigger more powerful. I think this is where we'll end up long-term. I am very keen to see A Forestal in the flesh.
1356415d1597260296-diy-e-gravel-m800-motor.jpg
Were you able to source that M800 off-the-shelf, or do you have a special arrangement with Bafang?
 

Rob Rides EMTB

Administrator
Staff member
Subscriber
Jan 14, 2018
6,260
13,700
Surrey, UK
Im following this with great interest, kudos to you for taking on this project and showing what can be achieved with a little research and ingenuity. Cant wait to see the ride review, and Im hoping to see a lot more about this build very soon.
One question though Rob, You don't seem to mention a charger at all, did this come with the bike as a package deal or is it something you had to buy separately?
Cheers! Charger included ?
 

patdam

Well-known member
Jan 17, 2019
902
601
france
attached display manual transmitted by bafang. but i am not sure it is the right (bluetooth is normally the C241? and this manual do not show assist mode qty adjust). in 2nd file iyou have the luna X1 display manual who explain assist mode qty setting
 

Attachments

  • BF-CM-DP C240.CAN .pdf
    2.4 MB · Views: 657
  • X-1 Enduro e-bike_.pdf
    374.8 KB · Views: 772
Last edited:

pragrick

Member
Oct 14, 2020
51
15
Prague
CHEBB, M500 motor. Are there any issues with getting the M600 instead. The frame you ordered can take the M500 or M600. Why not just take the 600, is there a problem with importing it? If it is used off road only? Is it a much larger drain on the battery? or just extra Nm if needed? And the display/controller for the motor? did they send that, what does it look like/cost?
 

Zimmerframe

MUPPET
Subscriber
Jun 12, 2019
14,028
20,818
Brittany, France
CHEBB, M500 motor. Are there any issues with getting the M600 instead. The frame you ordered can take the M500 or M600. Why not just take the 600, is there a problem with importing it? If it is used off road only? Is it a much larger drain on the battery? or just extra Nm if needed? And the display/controller for the motor? did they send that, what does it look like/cost?
There are a couple of things about the M600 compared to the M500.

The M600 runs all metal gears - so stronger, they had to do this because of the extra power. It also means it's louder than the M500. I think Luna ? make an alternative plastic gear for the M600 to make it quieter, no idea how this would affect reliability though.

The M600 is slightly heavier, so if you're trying to keep the weight down, it might not be the right choice for you.

The M600 is slightly wider (though uses the same mounting holes), I'm not sure if this also corresponds to a wider Q-factor which might be relevant for some riders. @Animalector ???

The M600, being more powerful, will use the battery quicker (if you use the power, but then if you never do, you might as well have the M500).

The M600, being more powerful, doesn't comply as a Pedalec, so in many places it would require insurance, registration plate, licence ? - depending on where you are.
 

Danny325is

New Member
Jan 3, 2021
5
9
NJ, USA
I spent a bit of time Chatting with Tony and unfortunately for me and my countrymen, this frame is not available for import to the USA.
Defang has an exclusive distributorship with an unnamed Company here in the US. I am making assumptions that this will be the frame for the upcoming Luna X-2 (or what ever replaces the x-1).

Super excited to see how this Bike turns out. If someone outside the US wants to order 2 and ship me one let me know.
 

Purpleaki

Member
Jan 6, 2021
8
8
UK
Hi, do you have a breakdown of the costs please?
Was the extra just on shipping or have they raised the price of the frame too?

I also got quoted the higher price of £1860.

Due to recent custom tariff changes, one thing to note is that the frame, motor and battery may be eligible for VAT upon entry into the UK. I don't think it is exempt from the tariff free trade negotiated in the latest Brexit agreement as the goods are not manufactured in the EU. Prior to Brexit, I think Dengfu used to ship through the EU and prepay the EU VAT tax, and then the goods entered the UK without customs duty. I am not sure how they are doing it now.

If VAT is applied upon entry into the UK, 20% of £1860 is an additional ~£360 without the customs handling charge (I think this is usually ~£15), so a total of ~£2200?. Still a great price, but the additional costs may be worth considering!

I'm in contact with Tony from Dengfu on this - will update you all when I get more information.
 
Last edited:

EMTB Forums

Since 2018

The World's largest electric mountain bike community.

555K
Messages
28,072
Members
Join Our Community

Latest articles


Top