I'm well aware of the strengths and weakensses of both Carbon fibre and Aluminium. In certain aspects Carbon is less durable than aluminium in others Carbon is stronger. Ideally you just have to weigh up the positives and negatives of each material and make an informed choice as which material is best for your needs (and wallet). Nothing is "break proof".Carbon fibre is stronger and more break proof than you think
David Copperfield making the statue of liberty disappear was astonishing tooyou will be astonished.
Here's Santa Cruz's strongest carbon fibre frame failing catastrophically