Removable or none removable battery ?

[ray.lambert]

Hi, do I go dedachable or nondedachable battery. Any advise would be appreciated.
Thanks

 

[#lazy]

Without any info my advice would be “flip a coin” !

 

[Bndit]

Benefit of non removable battery is that bike is probably lighter and stronger. Disadvantage that for example for working on your bike you cannot remove it so it's heavier to lift on to working stand, cable routing might be trickier to access etc.
Benefits of removable battery are opposite to above and disavantage is more weight, possible problems with battery covers etc. And of course much depends can you charge your bike indoors or not. Depnding of cable routing, I prefer fixed battery on emtb. Not that I haven't had one yet but didn't took Levo battery out so often or on current Bullit either. On Bullit it was also really easy to change rear brake and install lights because of removable battery...and change the battery also when it broke down...

 

[ray.lambert]

Without any info my advice would be “flip a coin” !

I'm looking at buying either 2024 crafty r or a turbo levo.

 

[ray.lambert]

Benefit of non removable battery is that bike is probably lighter and stronger. Disadvantage that for example for working on your bike you cannot remove it so it's heavier to lift on to working stand, cable routing might be trickier to access etc.
Benefits of removable battery are opposite to above and disavantage is more weight, possible problems with battery covers etc. And of course much depends can you charge your bike indoors or not. Depnding of cable routing, I prefer fixed battery on emtb. Not that I haven't had one yet but didn't took Levo battery out so often or on current Bullit either. On Bullit it was also really easy to change rear brake and install lights because of removable battery...and change the battery also when it broke down...

Hi yes I can charge it in the garage but if I'm away in the caravan it could be more difficult.

 

[irie]

Bosch motor.

 

[ray.lambert]

Bosch motor.

Yes both have bosch motors ?

 

[irie]

Yes both have bosch motors ?

2024 Crafty R has Bosch motor whereas Turbo Levo does not.

 

[Bndit]

I'm looking at buying either 2024 crafty r or a turbo levo.

Good options, have been thinking same as second ”back up” bike.

 

[ray.lambert]

2024 Crafty R has Bosch motor whereas Turbo Levo does not.

Sorry very true

 

[Binhill1]

My garage too cold so remove most times. If it's raining and you can't take bike indoors to charge eg hotel , hostel removable usefully again. I'm going away next week where I'm going insurance states no charging ebike on premises . Came across this a few times last year also asking in campsites to use circuit breaker plugs .

 

[steve_sordy]

"no charging ebikes on the premises" Yikes, I have never heard of that one! I hope that it doesn't catch on. This is one of the consequences of the insurance industry reacting to ill-informed media banging on about ebike fires.

 

[Binhill1]

"no charging ebikes on the premises" Yikes, I have never heard of that one! I hope that it doesn't catch on. This is one of the consequences of the insurance industry reacting to ill-informed media banging on about ebike fires.

Yes Steve afraid so , i was in Glenbrittle Memorial Hut in September its owned by Scottish mountaineering Club I believe. No bikes inside or outside not even under the porch no running of cables to charge outside. I'm staying in Elphin caving hut next week its owned by Grampian Speleological Group no charging Ebikes inside but you can run a waterproof extension to North end of carpark. Campsite i was looking at was Rcd plug required if you had hook up in a tent.Won't affect most people but I usually take a bike when I'm going away for the weekend with the walking club I'm in and do something enroute. All Insurance requirements is usually quoted.

 

[steve_sordy]

Yes Steve afraid so , i was in Glenbrittle Memorial Hut in September its owned by Scottish mountaineering Club I believe. No bikes inside or outside not even under the porch no running of cables to charge outside. I'm staying in Elphin caving hut next week its owned by Grampian Speleological Group no charging Ebikes inside but you can run a waterproof extension to North end of carpark. Campsite i was looking at was Rcd plug required if you had hook up in a tent.Won't affect most people but I usually take a bike when I'm going away for the weekend with the walking club I'm in and do something enroute. All Insurance requirements is usually quoted.

A bit of warning on the booking details would be nice.
I can see it now on a sign outside the door: "No travellers, no dogs, no smokers, no e-bikes".

Oh, and for the avoidance of doubt, the "travellers" in that amended quote above refers to travelling salesmen. The signs used to have a few other categories back in the 60's.

 

[Binhill1]

A bit of warning on the booking details would be nice.
I can see it now on a sign outside the door: "No travellers, no dogs, no smokers, no e-bikes".

Oh, and for the avoidance of doubt, the "travellers" in that amended quote above refers to travelling salesmen. The signs used to have a few other categories back in the 60's.

Yes the place I'm going no one there so it has code to get in how to switch gas on etc . This was all sent to me . QUOTE all in bold writing is insurance requirements. Sign of the times.

 

[Dave238]

Removable. I don't know what a "none" removable is (as opposed to a "non").

 

[Binhill1]

Removable. I don't know what a "none" removable is (as opposed to a "non").

Aye Ebikes nae arrived in Turra yet , yir ay shite ahin the door doon there .Ats a analogue yiv got . Just hud on min Buckie got yestreen

 

[#lazy]

If I stayed somewhere and it stipulated no electric shavers to be recharged I wouldn’t think twice about plugging one in !
Some of these rentals really take the piss , we staying at a cottage over Xmas that was very expensive and the oven keep tripping, the cinema room wasn’t wired properly and the dimmer light switches flickered !
Ps There wasn’t any effing pots and pans either !
Fxxk the lot of em

 

[ray.lambert]

Removable. I don't know what a "none" removable is (as opposed to a "non").

Obviously a small typo mistake??
Thanks for pointing it out

 

[Dax]

Obviously a small typo mistake??
Thanks for pointing it out

Lucky he pointed it out, we might have missed it otherwise

 

[Amber Valley Guy]

Easily removed batteries are great...but...if your bike has a down tube battery cover like mine.. moisture gets in their even when using a couple of velcro straps to hold it tight (Shimano). If you don't get in there and remove the battery after a wet ride (or wash) and remove the battery and wipe it dry and let it air out then your asking for trouble at some point (and I bet most people don't even check). I've had small puddles of water near the bottom of the down tube around the battery connection which I can 100% guarantee some people will be oblivious to...until it's to late.

 

[CrunchBytes]

I don’t think it matters re: removable or fixed, but I would say look into what batteries are ‘standard’ from the manufacturer. We have an Orbea Rise each and my partners integrated battery has failed at about 3 yrs old. Its propriety, specific to the Rise and can only be ordered from an Orbea dealer, and they have to order from Orbea direct. So far: £540 lighter, 3 weeks and we’re still waiting for it… I believe Bosch systems are more ‘standard’ so it should be easier to obtain a replacement if you ever need one. (PowerTube, PowerPack, PowerMore etc.). I’m guessing there will be differences in model years, but as Bosch makes the batteries for their motors, it should be generally easier to source.

My next ebike will take this into account (proprietary or standard battery size), as well as motor reliability, warranty, ease of fixing an outside of warranty failure, etc., etc.

 

[ray.lambert]

I don’t think it matters re: removable or fixed, but I would say look into what batteries are ‘standard’ from the manufacturer. We have an Orbea Rise each and my partners integrated battery has failed at about 3 yrs old. Its propriety, specific to the Rise and can only be ordered from an Orbea dealer, and they have to order from Orbea direct. So far: £540 lighter, 3 weeks and we’re still waiting for it… I believe Bosch systems are more ‘standard’ so it should be easier to obtain a replacement if you ever need one. (PowerTube, PowerPack, PowerMore etc.). I’m guessing there will be differences in model years, but as Bosch makes the batteries for their motors, it should be generally easier to source.

My next ebike will take this into account (proprietary or standard battery size), as well as motor reliability, warranty, ease of fixing an outside of warranty failure, etc.,

I don’t think it matters re: removable or fixed, but I would say look into what batteries are ‘standard’ from the manufacturer. We have an Orbea Rise each and my partners integrated battery has failed at about 3 yrs old. Its propriety, specific to the Rise and can only be ordered from an Orbea dealer, and they have to order from Orbea direct. So far: £540 lighter, 3 weeks and we’re still waiting for it… I believe Bosch systems are more ‘standard’ so it should be easier to obtain a replacement if you ever need one. (PowerTube, PowerPack, PowerMore etc.). I’m guessing there will be differences in model years, but as Bosch makes the batteries for their motors, it should be generally easier to source.

My next ebike will take this into account (proprietary or standard battery size), as well as motor reliability, warranty, ease of fixing an outside of warranty failure, etc., etc.

Some great advise there, thanks for that

 

[Bndit]

Easily removed batteries are great...but...if your bike has a down tube battery cover like mine.. moisture gets in their even when using a couple of velcro straps to hold it tight (Shimano). If you don't get in there and remove the battery after a wet ride (or wash) and remove the battery and wipe it dry and let it air out then your asking for trouble at some point (and I bet most people don't even check). I've had small puddles of water near the bottom of the down tube around the battery connection which I can 100% guarantee some people will be oblivious to...until it's to late.

Ebikes are designed so that water goes down and out from the frame. Problems starts if those holes at the bottom are clogged somehow. Or if you hose wash your bike upside down. I have two bikes with removable batteries and I ride all kind of shit weather and hose wash my bikes. My battery connections looks like they are new. I have never cleaned or protected them any way. But I store my bikes in warm place.

 

[Binhill1]

Ebikes are designed so that water goes down and out from the frame. Problems starts if those holes at the bottom are clogged somehow. Or if you hose wash your bike upside down. I have two bikes with removable batteries and I ride all kind of shit weather and hose wash my bikes. My battery connections looks like they are new. I have never cleaned or protected them any way. But I store my bikes in warm place.

Yes a warm place must help a lot My levo is filthy inside when I take cover off the side with cables. Not the easiest place to clean mud out of and small delicate wires on the plugs. . The hole in the bottom of the battery guard lets a lot of crap in to that area coming off the tyres or puddle splashing. Saying that cables been ok till three weeks ago I needed a new TCU.

 

[Bndit]

Yes a warm place must help a lot My levo is filthy inside when I take cover off the side with cables. Not the easiest place to clean mud out of and small delicate wires on the plugs. . The hole in the bottom of the battery guard lets a lot of crap in to that area coming off the tyres or puddle splashing. Saying that cables been ok till three weeks ago I needed a new TCU.

Yeah, I had Levo too. There was always dirt inside the motor cover but never moisture. There was known trick to stuff motofoam inside so that shit stays out but water can go through but I never used it.

 

[Binhill1]

Yeah, I had Levo too. There was always dirt inside the motor cover but never moisture. There was known trick to stuff motofoam inside so that shit stays out but water can go through but I never used it.

Just did that today. I am wondering is there a better cleaner bike out there for me. Sitting on fence regarding a new bike. I had a crack on bolt mountings and it broke off during torquing today so ???? . 5 and half years old , well a few of the original bits are . See what tomorrow brings.

 

[irie]

Our 2022 (alloy) Trek Rails came with removable batteries. Have now removed the battery lock hardware etc. with a large high up weight saving and batteries are now fixed in place using two bolts. No battery rattle either. Bikes are kept in a well insulated but unheated external garage, but if temps drop below typically 5C then use auxiliary heating.

When is an eMTB too heavy?

As @Plummet has said, it's when it's too heavy to lift over a fence especially towards the end of a ride when running out of energy. For me (as for Plummet) thats when the bike weighs over 26kg. Few weeks ago decided our 2022 (alloy) Rail 5's were getting too heavy so been putting them on a...

www.emtbforums.com

 

[kla456]

Removable is optimal for me: facilitates charging when travelling (in room), for a bit more bike security and battery sustainability/temperature when bike is in garage, for reduced weight on the car rack. I recommend this battery bag from Amazon - a 'must have' for today's heavy batteries.

 

[Paulquattro]

Removable. I don't know what a "none" removable is (as opposed to a "non").

Very helpful to the thread you should be proud of yourself



As for batterys i have no preference its a very personal choice .