First time emtb - build vs buy

DrStrangePepper

New Member
Mar 29, 2021
1
0
Seattle
I'm looking for some general guidance as a new-ish emtber.

My friend has a Trek 5 and I want to keep up with him.

I'll do XC with some light trails, but no huge drops or crazy life-threatening stuff.

I've been digging into the Trek specs and discovered that the baseline Trek 5 isn't all that impressive and I would probably want to upgrade components. I also looked at the Powerfly, but the price around here (Seattle) is $6k for what is available. And I'm hearing that Trek is moving away from Powerfly as a FS ebike and only hardtail.

I'm a DIY person, so I'm thinking I might go the DIY route.

I saw the Cheeb video and it seems like something I could do - but a bit hesitant because I've never built a bike before.

I know I want full-suspension, and a 29er, and good air fork/shocks. I'm 6'1", so probably a Trek Large size or 19" frame.

I found DIY Carbon Bikes - Quality. Affordable. Carbon. and they have a Rail like frame for $1395 and a fully built bike for $4500 with the Bafang M600 and specs:
Frame: DCB F150-E Trek Rail Style Carbon Full Suspension E Bike Frameset 29er or 27.5+
Built Specs (these specs, but with Rail frame and M600): 29er DCB F130 Trek Fuel Style Carbon Complete Trail Mountain Bike Full Suspension

But they only have a 2-3 year warranty on the frames, Trek has lifetime.

I think my options are:
1. Buy the Trek 5, learn on it, use it, upgrade it when I outgrow it. Pros: Easy, Cons: Budget eBike parts.
2. Buy Trek 7 to get slightly better components from the get go. Pros: Better specs, Cons: Cost
3. Buy the E10/E11 and build my own Cheeb - Pros: Specs are better than than Trek 5: Con: I haven't built a bike before.
4. Buy the bike from DIY Carbon Bikes - Pros: Specs are good, but bad warranty.
5. Buy a full-suspension normal non-electric bike and add a motor to it (upgrade kit) - Pros, probably cheaper, but motor not integrated into frame.
6. Other options that you'd recommend?

I've also considered Specialized and Cannondale, but I haven't been able to find a comparable bike the Trek 5, price and component wise.

Any guidance would be appreicated.

Thanks!
DrStrangePepper
 

Hamina

E*POWAH Master
Mar 22, 2020
500
396
FIN
I think my options are:
1. Buy the Trek 5, learn on it, use it, upgrade it when I outgrow it. Pros: Easy, Cons: Budget eBike parts.
2. Buy Trek 7 to get slightly better components from the get go. Pros: Better specs, Cons: Cost

I took the first option. Afterwards the Rail 7 would had been better it as has "good enough" components. I've now upgraded the Rail 5 over Rail 9 spec kinda. The Rail 5 weaknesses for me were the bit soft wheels with pinned rim joint and the Gold 35 RL front suspension.

I would put few thoughts also on resell value on DIY vs. brandbike.
 

EMTB Forums

Since 2018

The World's largest electric mountain bike community.

554K
Messages
28,010
Members
Join Our Community

Latest articles


Top